In simple terms, this quote suggests that Stuart Davis's work has a greater influence on defining what the United States represents compared to Edward Hopper's paintings. It implies that Davis's art offers deeper insights into American culture and identity.
The underlying message of this statement goes beyond mere artistic appreciation; it highlights the varying ways in which artists can reflect societal nuances. Donald Judd is pointing out that Stuart Davis, through his vibrant, abstract works infused with urban life imagery, captures the dynamic essence of America more effectively than Edward Hopper's often somber and reflective paintings might suggest. This comparison encourages viewers to consider how different artistic styles can reveal different aspects of a country’s character. By emphasizing Davis over Hopper, Judd challenges traditional perceptions about which artists truly encapsulate the spirit of their time and place.
Donald Judd was an influential American artist and critic known for his contributions to minimalism in sculpture and visual arts during the mid-20th century. His critical writings often focused on the importance of clarity and directness in artistic expression, making him well-positioned to comment on how different artists might embody cultural themes effectively.
