The quote suggests that individuals who identify as gay during their youth might share similarities with all young children, implying a universal innocence or positive traits often associated with childhood. It hints at the idea that these young people are viewed positively and perhaps even cherished for their inherent goodness.
On a deeper level, the statement critiques societal attitudes toward sexual orientation in younger individuals. By using the traditional nursery rhyme about making girls "of sugar and spice and everything nice," Dreger highlights how such stereotypes can be applied to young gay boys as well, suggesting that they are not inherently deviant or problematic but rather share the innocence and positivity of all children. However, there is also an undercurrent of irony in her statement, as she acknowledges the potential for offense by pointing out societal double standards and prejudices against certain groups.
Alice Dreger is a historian, author, and bioethicist known for her work on transgender issues and intersex rights. She has been an advocate for understanding and acceptance in medical ethics and social contexts, often challenging conventional views to promote more inclusive perspectives.
