In its most straightforward interpretation, this quote describes New York as a vast urban landscape that appears barren or desolate despite—or perhaps because of—the abundance of towering skyscrapers made from stone and concrete. The image evoked contrasts dramatically with the lush greenery and vibrant life often associated with more naturally beautiful environments.
On a deeper level, the statement reflects several dimensions of modern city life: the impersonal nature of urban existence, where vast numbers of people coexist in close proximity but remain isolated within their individual worlds; the relentless pace and constant hustle that can strip away the soul from daily living; and the sense of disconnection from natural surroundings, which are replaced by man-made structures. The "desert" metaphor captures these sentiments, highlighting how a city can feel both overwhelming and lonely at the same time.
Israel Zangwill was an English author born in London to Ashkenazi Jewish parents who immigrated there from Russia. He is best known for his work as a playwright, novelist, and essayist, with contributions that often focused on themes related to immigration and Jewish identity. His quote about New York encapsulates not only the physical characteristics of the city but also its cultural and emotional essence.
