In its literal sense, this quote emphasizes that judges must acknowledge their role within a legal framework that is built upon prior judicial decisions. Judges are part of a system where they interpret and apply laws based on precedents set by other judges who have similarly strived to uphold the principles of justice.
The deeper meaning of the statement reflects on the intricate relationship between individual judgment and collective jurisprudence. It suggests that while each judge is an independent thinker, their decisions are heavily influenced by a long history of legal interpretations established by predecessors. This acknowledgment of precedent underscores the importance of humility in judicial decision-making processes. Judges must respect the cumulative wisdom of the legal system while recognizing their own limitations and the contributions of others to shaping the law.
John Roberts, the author of this quote, is the Chief Justice of the United States. He has been a prominent figure in American jurisprudence for over two decades, with extensive experience both as a judge and earlier as a lawyer. His insights into judicial practice reflect his deep understanding of the legal system's structure and its role in maintaining societal order and justice.
