The speaker suggests that using open tunings can limit a musician's creativity because it becomes challenging to avoid sounding repetitive or predictable when playing songs in these tunings. Additionally, skills and techniques learned in one specific open tuning may not transfer well to others, which could hinder the development of versatile guitar playing.
On a deeper level, this quote touches on the broader theme of creative boundaries within musical practice. The speaker implies that while open tunings offer unique sonic landscapes and can inspire certain styles of music, they also risk becoming restrictive if relied upon too heavily. Musicians might find themselves stuck in a rut when they are overly dependent on these tunings, lacking the flexibility to explore different sounds or techniques. This limitation can stifle innovation and personal growth as an artist, urging musicians to diversify their skills by experimenting with standard tuning and other methods.
Leo Kottke is a renowned American guitarist known for his intricate fingerstyle playing and innovative use of open tunings. His unique style has influenced many guitarists in various genres such as folk and jazz, making him a significant figure in contemporary acoustic music.
