In essence, Samuel Butler's statement suggests that our perception of evil or wrongdoing is limited by the fact that we only hear one side of the story—typically from a perspective that favors a moral or divine viewpoint. This implies that there might be more to the narrative than what we are accustomed to believe.
The deeper meaning behind Butler’s quote challenges readers to critically examine their understanding of good and evil, suggesting that our judgment often lacks nuance because it is shaped by a singular, perhaps biased, perspective—namely, the belief in an omnipotent deity who has defined moral standards. The phrase "God has written all the books" underscores the idea that religious texts present one-sided narratives about morality and ethics, potentially leaving out alternative perspectives or explanations for actions deemed wicked. By advocating for considering the other side of the argument, Butler encourages a more balanced and reflective approach to understanding complex issues.
Samuel Butler was an English author who lived from 1835 to 1902. He is best known for his satirical novels that often questioned religious and moral certainties of his time. His works are characterized by their sharp wit and critical examination of Victorian society's norms, including religion and ethics.